
Elector · Papabile
Willem Jacobus Eijk
Dutch cardinal, Archbishop of Utrecht, physician and bioethicist, known for his very conservative positions on bioethical and moral issues, and his defense of traditional doctrine.
- Country
- Netherlands
- Born
- 22 June 1953 (73 years)
- Created cardinal
- by Benedict XVI, on 18 February 2012
- Status
- Elector · Elector until 22 June 2033
Overall position 76/100 · Conservative
Positions on six themes
How are these scores established?Each theme is scored from 0 (very progressive) to 10 (very conservative). The overall score, out of 100, weights the six themes.
-
Moral doctrine · 25 %
10/10Cardinal Eijk is one of the most explicit defenders of traditional moral teaching. In September 2022 he asked the Flemish bishops to withdraw their blessing liturgy for same-sex couples, saying it is 'not morally permissible to bless the homosexual relationship as such', while insisting that people with same-sex attraction deserve respect and pastoral care. He has criticised gender theory since 2016 and links it to the justification of abortion and assisted suicide. No personal statement of his on Fiducia Supplicans was found; the Dutch bishops' joint reply of January 2024 was cautious.
Sources (4)
- Cardinal Eijk: Same-sex blessings undermine Church teaching on marriage, sexual ethics — Catholic World Report / CNA, 2022-09-30
- Gender theory confusion shows need for papal encyclical, Dutch cardinal says — EWTN News / CNA, 2022-11-16
- Dutch cardinal says papal encyclical on gender theory might be needed — The Catholic Herald, 2016-11-08
- Dutch bishops offer cautious response to Vatican blessing guidance, bucking regional trend — Catholic World Report / CNA, 2024-01-19
-
Liturgy and tradition · 20 %
7/10On 15 March 2026 Cardinal Eijk celebrated his first Pontifical Mass in the traditional Roman rite in Oss, calling it 'a very impressive and unforgettable experience' and noting that most attendees were young. A Dutch press article questioned whether this fitted Traditionis Custodes; Bishop de Korte of Den Bosch defended it as pastoral care. In 2024 he said parishes with well-proclaimed faith and dignified liturgy are full. No public criticism by him of Traditionis Custodes has been found.
Sources (3)
- Cardinal Eijk celebrates his first Pontifical Mass in the traditional rite in the Netherlands — InfoVaticana, 2026-03-16
- Cardinal Eijk on first pontifical High Mass in the extraordinary form — The Catholic Herald, 2026-03-25
- Dutch cardinal advocates Christ-centered reform over controversial issues — Catholic World Report / CNA, 2024-10-16
-
Socio-political engagement · 15 %
7/10Cardinal Eijk's public interventions centre on human dignity and the protection of life. In an October 2026 interview he warned against a society that defines human dignity apart from God, using abortion legislation as an example and citing Evangelium Vitae. He has long opposed Dutch euthanasia law. No personal statement of his on migration, ecology or poverty has been found, and he is not linked to any political party.
-
Stance on Francis's reforms · 20 %
8/10In May 2018 Cardinal Eijk published an open letter accusing Pope Francis of 'creating confusion' and 'endangering the unity of the Church' over Communion for non-Catholic spouses in Germany; in 2015 he had said Amoris Laetitia should have stated more firmly that marriage is indissoluble. In October 2024 he compared the Synod on Synodality to the Dutch Pastoral Council of the 1960s and warned that ambiguity drives people away. Commentators framed his concern as one of governance and clarity.
Sources (3)
- Pope Francis accused by cardinal of 'endangering unity' of church — The Irish Times, 2018-05-09
- Cardinal Eijk, Pope Francis, and problems of governance — Catholic World Report, 2018-05-12
- Dutch cardinal advocates Christ-centered reform over controversial issues — Catholic World Report / CNA, 2024-10-16
-
Interreligious dialogue · 10 %
5/10In 2014 Cardinal Eijk stated that he remains warmly committed to ecumenism and fully supports the Pope's efforts toward Christian unity, while referring doctrinal discussion of the Council of Trent to the competent ecumenical bodies. No recent personal statement of his on Islam or Judaism was found, so his position is not strongly marked in the sources consulted.
-
Communication and pastoral style · 10 %
6/10Cardinal Eijk, a former physician, speaks in a classic and doctrinal register, stressing clarity of teaching and the effects of secularisation. He is regularly present in the Catholic press through interviews and articles, such as his 2024 interview on the synod and an October 2026 interview on human dignity.
Career
- 1999 – 2005Roman Catholic Bishop of Groningen
- 2005 – 2007Roman Catholic Bishop of Groningen-Leeuwarden
- since 2007Roman Catholic Archbishop of Utrecht
- since 2012Cardinal priest
- Episcopal consecration
- 17 July 1999
- Consecrators
- Adrianus Johannes Simonis, Frans Wiertz, Sergio Utleg
Official documents
- ‘God staat op de uitkijk’ Brief voor de Veertigdagentijd 2026
- Homilie herdenkingsmis paus Franciscus aan de vooravond van zijn uitvaart te Rome, Utrecht, Sint Catharinakathedraal, 25 april 2025
- Boodschap kardinaal Eijk voor de Veertigdagentijd 2025
- Aanbiedingsbrief Beleidsplan Blijft dit doen om Mij te gedenken
- Brief kardinaal Eijk voor de Veertigdagentijd 2020
- Brief kardinaal Eijk aan teams en besturen
- Vastenbrief van kardinaal Eijk, aartsbisschop van Utrecht (2014)
Why he is mentioned among the papabili
Background and Functions
Born on June 22, 1953, in Duivendrecht, Netherlands, Willem Jacobus Eijk is one of the few European cardinals to combine rigorous scientific training with solid theological expertise. Before entering the seminary, he studied medicine at the University of Amsterdam and briefly practiced as a physician. He then obtained a doctorate in medical bioethics from the University of Leiden, followed by a doctorate in philosophy from the Pontifical University of Saint Thomas Aquinas in Rome.
Ordained a priest in 1985 for the diocese of Roermond, he taught medical ethics and moral theology, while serving on the board of the Dutch pro-life medical association. In 1999, he was appointed Bishop of Groningen-Leeuwarden, then in 2007, Metropolitan Archbishop of Utrecht. He was created a cardinal by Benedict XVI at the consistory of February 18, 2012. (Dutch Willem Jacobus Eijk Photos and Premium High Res Pictures - Getty ...)
Cardinal Eijk is a member of several Roman dicasteries, including the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and the Dicastery for Health. He is also known for his public statements on bioethical issues, sexual morality, and doctrinal fidelity, particularly in the context of a highly secularized Dutch Church.
Analysis of Election Chances
Strengths
Clear doctrinal profile: Eijk is one of the few European cardinals to consistently defend a firm doctrinal line on sensitive issues such as euthanasia, abortion, marriage, and sexual identity.
Intellectual credibility: His dual training in medicine and philosophy makes him particularly respected in contemporary bioethical debates.
Pastoral experience in a challenging context: He has led the Dutch Church in an environment of rapid decline, giving him valuable experience facing the challenges of secularization.
Weaknesses
European origin: In a conclave where attention is increasingly turning toward the Global South, his European profile may be perceived as less representative of the Church's current dynamic.
Rigid positioning: His doctrinal firmness may be seen as a lack of openness to dialogue, particularly on complex pastoral issues.
Limited international visibility: Although influential in the Netherlands and in certain Roman circles, he remains relatively little known on the global ecclesiastical scene.
Ideological Positioning
Cardinal Eijk is clearly identified as a representative of the conservative current. He has expressed criticism of the synodal process in Germany and of certain orientations of the Synod on Synodality, warning against the risks of doctrinal confusion and ecclesial fragmentation. He advocates for the centrality of the Roman magisterium and strict fidelity to Catholic doctrine.
Network and Weight Within the College
Although not among the most high-profile figures in the College of Cardinals, Eijk enjoys a certain esteem among cardinals attached to tradition and doctrinal clarity. His election by Benedict XVI places him in the line of cardinals appointed for their fidelity to the magisterium. However, his influence remains limited compared to more central figures in the Curia or in major global dioceses.
To Learn More:
Cardinal Eijk asks the pope to clarify the question of intercommunion - Cath.ch, May 8, 2018
Who elects a new Pope and who are the main candidates to succeed Pope ... - Derry Journal, April 22, 2025



