Conclavoscope - Analysis of Catholic Church Cardinals

Ideological and pastoral positioning of cardinals

Next conclave in:

The Papabili for the 2025 Conclave

With Pope Francis's death, many are looking toward the next conclave. Here are the "papabili": cardinals considered most likely to succeed Francis. This analysis presents the most probable candidates, grouped according to their theological and pastoral tendencies.

A "papabile" is a cardinal considered to have a good chance of being elected pope in an upcoming conclave. This page presents an analysis of the main potential candidates classified by ideological tendency.
Ideological Distribution of Papabili

Filter by Tendency

Search for a Papabile

Traditionalist Cardinals

These cardinals are firmly attached to Catholic Tradition and strongly oppose recent reforms, particularly the restriction of the Tridentine Mass, secret agreements with China, communion for remarried divorcees, and blessings for same-sex couples.

Leading papabile
Robert Sarah
Robert Sarah
Guinea, 79 ans
Very conservative
Career and Functions

Born on June 15, 1945, in Ourous, Guinea, Robert Sarah was ordained a priest in 1969. At 34, in 1979, he became the Archbishop of Conakry, the youngest Catholic bishop at the time. He held this position until 2001, during which he resisted the Marxist regime of Sékou Touré, defending religious freedom and the autonomy of the Church. (Cardinal Robert Sarah: A Leading Contender for the Pope Office, Pope Francis accepts Cardinal Robert Sarah's resignation from ...)

In 2001, he was appointed Secretary of the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples, then President of the Pontifical Council Cor Unum in 2010. That same year, he was created cardinal by Benedict XVI. In 2014, Pope Francis appointed him Prefect of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, a position he held until his retirement in 2021. (Pope Francis accepts Cardinal Robert Sarah's resignation from ..., 14 cardinals will no longer be electors at the end of 2025 - Aleteia, Le cardinal Sarah ne sera bientôt plus électeur du Conclave - Aleteia)

Author of several influential works such as God or Nothing (2015), The Power of Silence (2016), and The Day Is Now Far Spent (2019), he is recognized for his defense of the traditional values of the Church.

Analysis of his chances of election as pope
Strengths and assets
  • Experience and international stature: With more than 40 years of episcopal service and key positions at the Vatican, he has a deep knowledge of the universal Church.
  • Respected spiritual figure: His writings and positions make him a reference for many faithful attached to tradition.
Weaknesses and limiting factors
  • Conservative positioning: His strong positions on sensitive issues may raise reluctance among more progressive cardinals.
  • Relations with Pope Francis: Although he has always affirmed his loyalty, some of his interventions have been perceived as critical of Pope Francis's orientations.
Ideological positioning

Cardinal Sarah is identified as a conservative figure, attached to traditional liturgy and the Church's classical moral teachings. He criticizes secularization and defends a vision of the Church centered on prayer, silence, and doctrinal fidelity.

Network and weight within the College of Cardinals

He has the support of cardinals who share his traditional convictions, particularly in Africa and Europe. However, the majority of cardinal electors having been created by Pope Francis, his influence could be limited compared to candidates more aligned with recent reforms.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report

Conservative Cardinals

These cardinals are aligned with the Ratzingerian line and are more conservative from a theological, moral, and pastoral point of view, while accepting the Second Vatican Council and its reforms.

Leading papabile
Gerhard Ludwig Müller
Gerhard Ludwig Müller
Germany, 77 ans
Conservative
Background and Functions

Born on December 31, 1947, in Finthen, near Mainz (Germany), Gerhard Ludwig Müller was ordained a priest in 1978. He earned a doctorate in theology under the direction of Cardinal Karl Lehmann, with a thesis on Dietrich Bonhoeffer. In 1986, he became professor of dogmatic theology at Ludwig-Maximilian University in Munich. (Gerhard Ludwig Müller - Wikipedia, Gerhard Ludwig Müller, Liberation Theology Interview with Archbishop Gerhard Ludwig Müller)

Appointed Bishop of Regensburg in 2002 by John Paul II, he distinguished himself through his proximity to Joseph Ratzinger, the future Benedict XVI, who entrusted him with the German edition of his complete works.

In 2012, Benedict XVI appointed him Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, a position he held until 2017. He was created a cardinal by Pope Francis in 2014. (Cardinal Gerhard Müller: le pape au COE, un bon signe pour l'œcuménisme ..., Gerhard Ludwig Müller Biography - Pantheon World)

Current Influence

Since the end of his mandate as head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Cardinal Müller has become one of the main figures of the conservative current within the Catholic Church. He regularly criticizes certain orientations of Pope Francis's pontificate, particularly regarding doctrine and sacramental discipline. (Cardinal Gerhard Müller: le pape au COE, un bon signe pour l'œcuménisme ..., Gerhard Ludwig Müller)

Analysis of Election Chances
Strengths and Assets
Weaknesses and Factors Limiting His Election
Ideological Positioning

Cardinal Müller is identified as a representative of the conservative current. He insists on fidelity to the traditional doctrine of the Church and expresses reservations about certain recent pastoral developments, particularly regarding sexual morality and sacramental discipline.

Network and Weight Within the College of Cardinals

Although appointed cardinal by Francis, he is close to conservative circles, particularly in Europe and North America. However, the majority of cardinal electors having been created by Francis, his direct influence within the electoral college is limited. (Cardinal Müller: Church risks split if it elects a liberal pope)

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Leading papabile
Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet
Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet
Uruguay, 65 ans
Conservative
Career and Functions

Born on July 4, 1959, in Montevideo (Uruguay), Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet is the youngest of five siblings. Orphaned in adolescence, he was deeply influenced by Salesian spirituality, which he discovered at the John XXIII Institute in Montevideo. He entered the Society of St. Francis de Sales (Salesians of Don Bosco) in 1979 and took his religious vows on January 31, 1980. (Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet, Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet)

After studies in civil law, philosophy, education sciences, and theology, he was ordained a priest on November 21, 1987. He then held various positions of responsibility within the Salesians in Uruguay: master of novices, director of the John XXIII Institute, professor of Church history, and then provincial of the order in 2008. In 2009, he was elected president of the Conference of Religious of Uruguay. (Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet)

On December 10, 2011, he was appointed auxiliary bishop of Montevideo by Pope Benedict XVI and received episcopal consecration on March 4, 2012. On February 11, 2014, Pope Francis appointed him metropolitan archbishop of Montevideo. He was created cardinal on February 14, 2015, receiving the title of Cardinal-Priest of Santa Galla. (Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet, Daniel Sturla)

Within the Roman Curia, he is a member of several dicasteries, including the Congregation for Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life, the Pontifical Council for the Promotion of the New Evangelization, the Pontifical Commission for Latin America, and the Cardinal Commission of the Administration of the Patrimony of the Apostolic See. (Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet)

Analysis of his election chances
Strengths and assets
  • Proximity to Pope Francis: His rapid appointment as archbishop and then cardinal testifies to the trust placed in him by Pope Francis. (Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet)
  • Diverse pastoral experience: His career within the Salesians and his episcopal responsibilities give him solid experience in ecclesiastical governance. (Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet)
  • Latin American anchoring: Coming from a dynamic region of the Catholic Church, he could represent geographical continuity after Francis's pontificate.
Weaknesses and limiting factors
  • Conservative ideological positioning: Although close to Pope Francis, he is perceived as having conservative positions, particularly on issues such as the blessing of same-sex couples, which could raise concerns among progressive cardinals.
  • Lack of international visibility: Less known on the world stage than other papabili, his profile might not gather sufficient consensus within the College of Cardinals.
Ideological positioning

Cardinal Sturla is generally considered conservative. He has expressed criticism of documents such as Fiducia supplicans, calling it "ambiguous, divisive, and confusing." He is also skeptical about the concept of synodality. (Who Will Be The Next Pope? - BIG C CATHOLICS)

Network and weight within the College of Cardinals

As a member of several Roman dicasteries and an influential figure in Latin America, he has an extensive network. However, his influence within the College of Cardinals remains moderate compared to more prominent figures.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Mauro Piacenza
Mauro Piacenza
Italy, 80 ans
Very conservative
Background and Functions

Born on September 15, 1944, in Genoa, Mauro Piacenza is one of the few European cardinals to combine a rigorous scientific training with solid theological expertise. He was ordained a priest in 1969 by Cardinal Giuseppe Siri. With a doctorate in canon law from the Pontifical Lateran University, he held various pastoral and academic ministries in his native diocese, including teaching dogmatic theology and the history of atheism. He also served as a judge in the ecclesiastical tribunal and as the diocesan assistant for the Ecclesial Movement for Cultural Commitment. (Mauro Piacenza, Mauro Piacenza)

In 1990, he joined the Roman Curia in the Congregation for the Clergy, where he successively served as bureau chief (1997), under-secretary (2000), and then secretary (2007). In 2003, John Paul II appointed him president of the Pontifical Commission for the Cultural Heritage of the Church and titular bishop of Victoriana. He was consecrated bishop on November 15, 2003, by Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone. In 2004, he also became president of the Pontifical Commission for Sacred Archaeology. (Mauro Piacenza)

On October 7, 2010, Benedict XVI appointed him Prefect of the Congregation for the Clergy and president of the International Council for Catechesis. He was created a cardinal on November 20, 2010, with the title of San Paolo alle Tre Fontane. In 2011, he was appointed international president of the pontifical foundation Aid to the Church in Need. (Mauro Piacenza, Mauro Piacenza)

On September 21, 2013, Pope Francis appointed him Major Penitentiary of the Apostolic Penitentiary, a position he held until April 6, 2024. On May 3, 2021, he was elevated to the order of cardinal-priests. He reached the age of 80 on September 15, 2024, thus losing his right to vote in the conclave. (Mauro Piacenza, Mauro Piacenza)

Analysis of His Election Chances as Pope
Strengths and Assets Weaknesses and Limiting Factors
  • Advanced age: having reached 80 years old in September 2024, he is no longer an elector in the conclave and thus cannot be elected pope.
  • Conservative ideological positioning, which could be seen as a hindrance in an ecclesiastical context seeking reforms.
  • Less media visibility compared to other more active cardinals on the international scene.
Ideological Positioning

Cardinal Piacenza is considered a conservative, attached to tradition and ecclesiastical discipline. He has often warned against moral relativism and emphasized the importance of the sacrament of confession. His theological approach is centered on fidelity to the magisterium and defense of the Church's traditional values.

Network and Weight Within the College of Cardinals

Although he was influential under Benedict XVI's pontificate, his influence has diminished under Pope Francis. His network primarily consists of conservative cardinals and prelates. However, his withdrawal from the electoral college now limits his weight in future decisions.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Leading papabile
Albert Malcolm Ranjith Patabendige Don
Albert Malcolm Ranjith Patabendige Don
Sri Lanka, 77 ans
Conservative
Career and Functions

Born on November 15, 1947, in Polgahawela, Sri Lanka, Cardinal Albert Malcolm Ranjith Patabendige Don is a prominent figure in the Asian Catholic Church. Ordained a priest in 1975, he pursued his studies in Rome, obtaining a license in biblical theology from the Pontifical Urban University. (24 Albert Malcolm Ranjith Patabendige Stock Photos, High-Res Pictures ...)

His ecclesiastical career is marked by an alternation between pastoral responsibilities and functions within the Roman Curia. He notably served as Assistant Secretary to the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples and as Apostolic Nuncio to Indonesia and East Timor. In 2005, he was appointed Secretary of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, before being appointed Archbishop of Colombo in 2009. He was created cardinal by Pope Benedict XVI in 2010. (Revue de presse : De quel continent viendra le prochain Pape ?, How Old Will the Next Pope Be? - National Catholic Register)

As Archbishop of Colombo, he played a central role in the religious and social life of Sri Lanka, notably calling for justice and reconciliation after the Easter 2019 attacks. He is also known for his critical positions towards certain Sri Lankan government policies.

Analysis of his chances of election as pope
Strengths and assets
  • Curial experience: His service within the Roman Curia gives him an in-depth knowledge of the governance mechanisms of the universal Church.
  • Traditional liturgical profile: Close to Pope Benedict XVI, he is recognized for his attachment to traditional liturgy, which may appeal to cardinals wishing for a return to a certain liturgical rigor.
  • Asian origin: His origin from Asia, a continent where Catholicism is growing, could represent an opening towards the local Churches of this region.
Weaknesses and factors limiting his election
  • Advanced age: At 77, his age could be a deterrent for cardinals wishing for a longer pontificate.
  • Limited media visibility: Less mediatized than other papabili, he could suffer from a lesser notoriety within the College of Cardinals.
Ideological positioning

Cardinal Ranjith is considered a conservative, particularly in liturgical and doctrinal matters. He is often associated with Pope Benedict XVI's line of thought. However, he is not perceived as a frontal opponent to Pope Francis's reforms, adopting rather a posture of discretion and fidelity to the institution.

Network and weight within the College of Cardinals

Although he has established relationships within the Curia and among Asian cardinals, his influence seems limited compared to the more extensive networks of some other papabili. His profile could nevertheless appeal to a minority of cardinals wishing for a return to certain traditions.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Leading papabile
Willem Jacobus Eijk
Willem Jacobus Eijk
Netherlands, 71 ans
Conservative
Background and Functions

Born on June 22, 1953, in Duivendrecht, Netherlands, Willem Jacobus Eijk is one of the few European cardinals to combine rigorous scientific training with solid theological expertise. Before entering the seminary, he studied medicine at the University of Amsterdam and briefly practiced as a physician. He then obtained a doctorate in medical bioethics from the University of Leiden, followed by a doctorate in philosophy from the Pontifical University of Saint Thomas Aquinas in Rome.

Ordained a priest in 1985 for the diocese of Roermond, he taught medical ethics and moral theology, while serving on the board of the Dutch pro-life medical association. In 1999, he was appointed Bishop of Groningen-Leeuwarden, then in 2007, Metropolitan Archbishop of Utrecht. He was created a cardinal by Benedict XVI at the consistory of February 18, 2012. (Dutch Willem Jacobus Eijk Photos and Premium High Res Pictures - Getty ...)

Cardinal Eijk is a member of several Roman dicasteries, including the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and the Dicastery for Health. He is also known for his public statements on bioethical issues, sexual morality, and doctrinal fidelity, particularly in the context of a highly secularized Dutch Church.

Analysis of Election Chances
Strengths
  • Clear doctrinal profile: Eijk is one of the few European cardinals to consistently defend a firm doctrinal line on sensitive issues such as euthanasia, abortion, marriage, and sexual identity.
  • Intellectual credibility: His dual training in medicine and philosophy makes him particularly respected in contemporary bioethical debates.
  • Pastoral experience in a challenging context: He has led the Dutch Church in an environment of rapid decline, giving him valuable experience facing the challenges of secularization.
Weaknesses
  • European origin: In a conclave where attention is increasingly turning toward the Global South, his European profile may be perceived as less representative of the Church's current dynamic.
  • Rigid positioning: His doctrinal firmness may be seen as a lack of openness to dialogue, particularly on complex pastoral issues.
  • Limited international visibility: Although influential in the Netherlands and in certain Roman circles, he remains relatively little known on the global ecclesiastical scene.
Ideological Positioning

Cardinal Eijk is clearly identified as a representative of the conservative current. He has expressed criticism of the synodal process in Germany and of certain orientations of the Synod on Synodality, warning against the risks of doctrinal confusion and ecclesial fragmentation. He advocates for the centrality of the Roman magisterium and strict fidelity to Catholic doctrine.

Network and Weight Within the College

Although not among the most high-profile figures in the College of Cardinals, Eijk enjoys a certain esteem among cardinals attached to tradition and doctrinal clarity. His election by Benedict XVI places him in the line of cardinals appointed for their fidelity to the magisterium. However, his influence remains limited compared to more central figures in the Curia or in major global dioceses.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Leading papabile
Péter Erdő
Péter Erdő
Hungary, 72 ans
Moderate-conservative
Background and Functions

Born on June 25, 1952, in Budapest, Péter Erdő is a major figure in the Hungarian Catholic Church. Ordained a priest in 1975, he was appointed Archbishop of Esztergom-Budapest in 2002 and created a cardinal by John Paul II in 2003. He has also been president of the Hungarian Episcopal Conference since 2005 and presided over the Council of European Episcopal Conferences from 2006 to 2016. (Péter Erdő)

A recognized specialist in canon law, he was a professor at the Péter Pázmány Catholic University and has published numerous academic works. His theological and legal expertise has earned him notable influence within the Vatican, particularly as general rapporteur of the Synod on the Family in 2014. (Le nom des cardinaux 'papabile' qui reviennent le plus souvent, Hungary's Péter Erdő is a strong candidate to be the next pope - and that's reason to be fearful)

Multilingual, he speaks Hungarian, Italian, French, English, and Latin fluently. He is also known for his Marian devotion, particularly to Our Lady of Consolation.

Analysis of Election Chances
Strengths and Assets
  • International experience and stature: With over two decades leading the Hungarian Church and European responsibilities, Erdő possesses solid pastoral and administrative experience.
  • Theological competence: His expertise in canon law and active participation in synods give him respected doctrinal authority.
  • Consensus profile: As a moderate conservative, he is perceived as a figure capable of uniting different sensibilities within the College of Cardinals.
Weaknesses and Limiting Factors
Ideological Positioning

Erdő is generally classified among moderate conservatives. He defends a strict interpretation of Catholic doctrine, particularly on issues of family and sexuality, while avoiding extreme positions. He has expressed reservations about expanding the rights of LGBTQ+ people and remarried divorcees within the Church. (Hungary's Péter Erdő is a strong candidate to be the next pope - and that's reason to be fearful)

Network and Weight Within the College of Cardinals

Although the majority of cardinal electors have been appointed by Pope Francis, Erdő benefits from a solid network, particularly in Central and Eastern Europe. His academic profile and synodal experience give him credibility among many cardinals, including those in Africa and Latin America.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Leading papabile
Pierbattista Pizzaballa
Pierbattista Pizzaballa
Israel, 60 ans
Moderate-conservative
Career and Functions

Born on April 21, 1965, in Cologno al Serio, near Bergamo in Italy, Pierbattista Pizzaballa is a Franciscan who has dedicated most of his priestly life to the Holy Land. Ordained a priest in 1990 by Cardinal Giacomo Biffi, he joined the Franciscan Custody of the Holy Land in 1999, where he held various positions, including superior of the Convent of Saints Simeon and Anne in Jerusalem. (Pierbattista Pizzaballa)

In 2004, he was elected Custos of the Holy Land, a role he held until 2016. During this period, he distinguished himself through his efforts in interreligious dialogue and his commitment to peace. In 2016, he was appointed apostolic administrator of the Latin Patriarchate of Jerusalem, and then became its patriarch in 2020. He was created cardinal by Pope Francis in September 2023. (Pierbattista Pizzaballa)

Analysis of Election Chances
Strengths and Assets
  • Experience in interreligious dialogue: Pizzaballa has demonstrated a remarkable ability to build bridges between Christian, Jewish, and Muslim communities in the Holy Land. He notably organized a prayer for peace at the Vatican in 2014, bringing together the Israeli and Palestinian presidents. (Papabile of the day: Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa – the bridge ...)
  • Linguistic and cultural skills: Mastering Hebrew and Arabic, he is deeply rooted in the complex reality of the region, which gives him a unique perspective on the global challenges of the Church.
Weaknesses and Limiting Factors
  • Lack of doctrinal clarity: His positioning on certain controversial theological questions remains unclear, which could raise concerns among electors seeking a more defined orientation.
Ideological Positioning

Pizzaballa is perceived as a moderate, avoiding both progressive and conservative extremes. This neutrality could make him acceptable to various currents within the College of Cardinals. (Le nom des cardinaux 'papabile' qui reviennent le plus souvent)

Network and Weight within the College of Cardinals

Although he was created cardinal recently, his reputation as a mediator and his experience as Patriarch of Jerusalem give him a respected stature. His international profile and commitment to peace could appeal to a College of Cardinals wishing to unify the Church around values of dialogue and reconciliation. (Cardinal Pizzaballa's Meteoric Rise to 'Papabile')

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Angelo Bagnasco
Angelo Bagnasco
Italy, 82 ans
Conservative
Background and Functions

Born on January 14, 1943, in Pontevico, Italy, Angelo Bagnasco was ordained a priest on June 29, 1966, by Cardinal Giuseppe Siri. He obtained a doctorate in philosophy from the University of Genoa in 1979 and taught metaphysics and contemporary atheism at the Theological Faculty of Northern Italy until 1998. (Cardinal Angelo Bagnasco)

He was appointed Bishop of Pesaro in 1998, then promoted to Archbishop in 2000. In 2003, he became Military Ordinary for Italy, before being appointed Archbishop of Genoa in 2006. Created a cardinal by Benedict XVI in 2007, he was president of the Italian Episcopal Conference (CEI) from 2007 to 2017 and president of the Council of European Episcopal Conferences (CCEE) from 2016 to 2021. He retired as Archbishop of Genoa in 2020. (Angelo Cardinal Bagnasco - Catholic-Hierarchy, Angelo Bagnasco Biography - Pantheon World)

Analysis of Election Chances
Strengths and Assets
  • Extensive experience: Bagnasco has held high-level positions within the Church, including as president of the CEI and CCEE, giving him an in-depth knowledge of ecclesiastical affairs at both national and European levels.
  • Solid intellectual training: With a doctorate in philosophy and an academic career, he is recognized for his intellectual rigor and ability to articulate Catholic doctrine.
  • Recognized leadership: His role in the management of the Italian and European Church has demonstrated his skills in governance and ecclesiastical diplomacy.
Weaknesses and Factors Limiting His Election
  • Advanced age: Having reached the age of 80 in January 2023, he has lost his right to vote in the conclave, making him ineligible for papal election.
  • Conservative positioning: His alignment with conservative positions may not correspond to the current orientation of the Church under Pope Francis's pontificate.
Ideological Positioning

Bagnasco is considered a conservative, faithful to the doctrinal tradition of the Church. He has expressed firm positions on issues such as euthanasia, abortion, and homosexual marriage, which he described as a "Trojan horse" for society.

Network and Weight Within the College of Cardinals

Although he has been an influential figure within the Italian and European Church, his current influence is limited due to his age and retirement. However, he remains respected for his experience and contribution to the Church.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Leading papabile
Charles Maung Bo
Charles Maung Bo
Myanmar, 76 ans
Moderate-conservative
Background and Functions

Born in 1948 in Monhla, Burma (Myanmar), Charles Maung Bo joined the Salesian Society of Don Bosco and was ordained a priest in 1976. He was appointed Bishop of Lashio in 1990, then Archbishop of Yangon in 2003. In 2015, he was created a cardinal by Pope Francis, thus becoming the first Burmese cardinal.

He also served as president of the Federation of Asian Bishops' Conferences (FABC) from 2018 to 2022, playing a key role in coordinating the Church's pastoral and social efforts in Asia. As a member of the Pontifical Council for Interreligious Dialogue, he has worked to promote peace and reconciliation in a country marked by ethnic and religious conflicts.

Analysis of Election Chances
Strengths and Assets
  • Pastoral experience in a context of persecution: His long experience in a country where Christians are a minority and often persecuted gives him moral credibility and a deep understanding of the challenges facing the Church in difficult contexts.
  • Commitment to peace and interreligious dialogue: His work for reconciliation between different religious and ethnic communities in Myanmar testifies to his commitment to a Church open to dialogue.
  • Representation of the Church in Asia: As a major figure in the Asian Church, his election would be a strong sign of the universality of the Church and the growing importance of Asia in world Catholicism.
Weaknesses and Factors Limiting His Election
  • Advanced age: Born in 1948, he would be 77 years old at the 2025 conclave, which could be a deterrent for cardinals wishing for a longer pontificate.
  • Limited visibility at the Vatican: Although he has held important positions in Asia, he has not had a major role within the Roman Curia, which could limit his recognition among some electors.
Ideological Positioning

Cardinal Bo is often perceived as a moderate, combining fidelity to Catholic doctrine and openness to interreligious and social dialogue. He embodies a Church engaged on issues of social justice, peace, and human rights, without adopting radical theological positions.

Network and Weight Within the College of Cardinals

His role as president of the FABC has allowed him to forge close ties with many Asian bishops and cardinals. However, his direct influence within the College of Cardinals remains limited, particularly due to his low presence at the Vatican and the predominance of European and American cardinals.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Marc Ouellet
Marc Ouellet
Canada, 80 ans
Conservative
Background and Functions

Marc Ouellet was born on June 8, 1944, in La Motte, Quebec. Ordained a priest in 1968, he joined the Society of Saint Sulpice in 1972. A theologian by training, he taught in various seminaries in Canada, Colombia, and Rome. In 2001, he was appointed secretary of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, then Archbishop of Quebec in 2002. He was created a cardinal in 2003 by John Paul II.

In 2010, Benedict XVI appointed him Prefect of the Congregation for Bishops (now the Dicastery for Bishops), a position he held until 2023. In this capacity, he played a central role in the appointment of bishops worldwide. He was also president of the Pontifical Commission for Latin America.

During his mandate, he vigorously defended priestly celibacy, particularly during the Synod for the Amazon in 2019, when he published the book Friends of the Bridegroom to reaffirm the importance of this discipline in the Latin Church.

Analysis of Election Chances
Strengths and Assets
  • Experience within the Roman Curia: His role as Prefect of the Dicastery for Bishops gave him in-depth knowledge of the global episcopate and the workings of the Curia.
  • Respected theologian: His intellectual formation and commitment to priestly formation are widely recognized.
  • Proximity to Popes Benedict XVI and Francis: He has worked closely with both pontiffs, giving him an image of continuity between different currents in the Church.
Weaknesses and Limiting Factors
  • Advanced age: At 80 years old, he has reached the age limit to participate in the conclave and is therefore no longer an elector.
  • Accusations of poor management: In 2024, a French court convicted him for expelling a nun without a valid pontifical mandate, which tarnished his reputation.
  • Allegations of sexual misconduct: Although the Vatican judged there was insufficient evidence to open a canonical investigation, these accusations have damaged his public image.
Ideological Positioning

Cardinal Ouellet is considered a moderate conservative. He defends traditional positions on issues such as priestly celibacy and opposes the ordination of women. However, he has also supported some of Pope Francis's reforms, particularly regarding the selection of bishops, favoring pastoral profiles close to the people.

Network and Weight Within the College of Cardinals

Although he is no longer an elector, his influence remains notable due to his years as head of the Dicastery for Bishops. He has contributed to the appointment of many bishops and cardinals, giving him an extensive network within the Church. However, his recent retirement and controversies have distanced him from the current center of decisions.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Leading papabile
Anders Arborelius
Anders Arborelius
Sweden, 75 ans
Moderate-conservative
Background and Functions

Born on September 24, 1949, in Sorengo, Switzerland, to Swedish parents, Anders Arborelius grew up in Lund, in southern Sweden. Coming from a non-practicing Lutheran family, he converted to Catholicism at the age of 20, after being influenced by the Bridgettine sisters and reading the autobiography of Saint Thérèse of Lisieux. Two years later, he entered the Discalced Carmelites at the monastery of Norraby. He made his perpetual vows in 1977 in Bruges and was ordained a priest in 1979 in Malmö.

Holding a degree in modern languages from the University of Lund and a doctorate in theology from the Teresianum in Rome, he was appointed Bishop of Stockholm in 1998 by John Paul II, thus becoming the first Swedish Catholic bishop since the Reformation. In 2017, Pope Francis created him a cardinal, making him the first cardinal in the history of Sweden and Scandinavia.

Within the Roman Curia, he has been a member of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, the Congregation for the Clergy, the Congregation for Eastern Churches, the Council for the Economy, and the Dicastery for Bishops. He also presided over the Scandinavian Bishops' Conference from 2005 to 2015.

Analysis of His Election Chances
Strengths and Assets
  • Pastoral experience in a minority context: As head of a Catholic Church representing about 1.5% of the Swedish population, he has managed a diverse community, consisting mostly of immigrants, promoting unity and integration.
  • Ecumenical commitment: A key player in interfaith dialogue in Sweden, he has worked closely with Lutheran authorities, particularly during Pope Francis' visit in 2016 to commemorate the 500th anniversary of the Reformation.
  • Proximity to the peripheries: His elevation to the cardinalate by Pope Francis symbolizes the attention given to Churches in geographical and cultural peripheries.
  • Reputation for moderation: Appreciated by both conservatives and progressives, he is perceived as a consensus figure within the Church.
Weaknesses and Factors Limiting His Election
  • Advanced age: At 75 years old, if elected, he would be one of the oldest popes at the time of his election, which might dissuade cardinals wishing for a longer pontificate.
  • Limited visibility: Little known outside Scandinavia, he does not enjoy the international reputation of other papabili.
  • Lack of diplomatic experience: Unlike some candidates who have held diplomatic posts within the Holy See, he does not have a background in this field.
Ideological Positioning

Cardinal Arborelius is considered moderate, with a deep spiritual sensitivity inherited from his Carmelite formation. He emphasizes mercy, unity, and dialogue, while remaining faithful to the traditional teaching of the Church. He has expressed his discomfort with speculation about the conclave and emphasized the importance of not politicizing the papal election.

Network and Weight Within the College of Cardinals

Although he is not among the most influential figures in the College of Cardinals, his participation in various dicasteries and his commitment to Christian unity give him a certain recognition. His profile as a humble and experienced pastor could appeal to cardinals looking for a transitional candidate, capable of maintaining balance within the Church.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report

Moderate Cardinals

These cardinals occupy an intermediate position, very discreet in their assertions, but who are very likely sympathetic to the "Francis Party" while maintaining some more traditional positions.

Leading papabile
Jean-Marc Aveline
Jean-Marc Aveline
France, 66 ans
Moderate-progressive
Background and Functions

Jean-Marc Aveline was born on December 26, 1958, in Sidi Bel Abbès, French Algeria. After independence, his family settled in Marseille, where he completed his schooling. He entered the Avignon interdiocesian seminary in 1977, then continued his studies at the Carmes seminary in Paris, obtaining a double degree in theology and philosophy, as well as a master's degree in theology. In 2000, he defended a doctoral thesis entitled For a Christological Theology of Religions.

Ordained a priest on November 3, 1984, for the Archdiocese of Marseille, he held various positions related to theological training and interreligious dialogue. In 1992, he founded the Institute of Science and Theology of Religions (ISTR) in Marseille, which he directed until 2002. He was also director of the Catholic Institute of the Mediterranean and taught at the theology faculty of the Catholic University of Lyon.

Appointed Auxiliary Bishop of Marseille in 2013, he became Metropolitan Archbishop of Marseille in 2019. On August 27, 2022, he was created a cardinal by Pope Francis, with the title of Cardinal Priest of Santa Maria ai Monti. He is a member of the Dicastery for Bishops and the Dicastery for Interreligious Dialogue.

On April 2, 2025, he was elected President of the French Bishops' Conference, with his term scheduled to begin on July 1, 2025.

Analysis of His Election Chances
Strengths and Assets
  • Proximity to Pope Francis: Cardinal Aveline shares Pope Francis's pastoral and missionary vision, particularly regarding attention to the peripheries and interreligious dialogue. He hosted the Pope in Marseille in September 2023 during the Mediterranean Meetings, thus enhancing his international visibility.
  • Experience in interreligious dialogue: Founder of the ISTR and member of the Dicastery for Interreligious Dialogue, he is recognized for his commitment to dialogue with Islam, an asset in a world marked by religious tensions.
  • National leadership: His election as President of the French Bishops' Conference testifies to the confidence his peers place in him and his ability to unite.
Weaknesses and Limiting Factors
  • Command of Italian: His relative mastery of the Italian language could be an obstacle in a context where Italian is the working language at the Vatican.
  • Limited international visibility: Although he is known in France and in certain ecclesiastical circles, he does not yet have a global reputation comparable to that of other papabili.
Ideological Positioning

Cardinal Aveline is considered moderately progressive. He supports a Church open to dialogue, attentive to contemporary challenges such as migration and secularization. He embodies a balanced line between tradition and openness, in line with Pope Francis's legacy.

Network and Weight Within the College of Cardinals

He enjoys the support of influential cardinals such as Jean-Claude Hollerich and Reinhard Marx. His appointment by Pope Francis and his active participation in synods strengthen his position within the College of Cardinals. Moreover, his role as President of the French Bishops' Conference gives him additional legitimacy.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Leading papabile
Fridolin Ambongo Besungu
Fridolin Ambongo Besungu
Democratic Republic of the Congo, 65 ans
Moderate-progressive
Background and Functions

Fridolin Ambongo Besungu was born on January 24, 1960, in Boto, Democratic Republic of Congo. Ordained a priest in 1988 as a member of the Capuchin Order, he obtained a licentiate in moral theology at the Alphonsian Academy in Rome. He was appointed Bishop of Bokungu-Ikela in 2004 by John Paul II, then apostolic administrator of Kole in 2008. In 2016, he became Archbishop of Mbandaka-Bikoro, before being appointed coadjutor of Kinshasa in 2018, succeeding Laurent Monsengwo Pasinya. He was created cardinal by Pope Francis in October 2019. (Quién es Fridolin Ambongo Besungu, el papable que puede ser el primer papa africano en 16 siglos, Fridolin Ambongo Besungu)

Ambongo has been a member of the Council of Cardinals since 2020, a select group tasked with advising the Pope on the reform of the Roman Curia. In February 2023, he was elected president of the Symposium of Episcopal Conferences of Africa and Madagascar (SECAM), thus strengthening his influence on the African continent. (Le nom des cardinaux 'papabile' qui reviennent le plus souvent, Fridolin Ambongo Besungu)

He is known for his commitment to social justice, denouncing corruption, exploitation of natural resources, and foreign interference in Africa. He has also played an active role in political mediation in the Democratic Republic of Congo, particularly during the 2018 elections. (Quién es Fridolin Ambongo Besungu, el papable que puede ser el primer papa africano en 16 siglos)

Analysis of His Election Chances
Strengths and Assets
  • Continental leadership: As president of SECAM, Ambongo is the main voice of the African Church, representing a region experiencing demographic and spiritual growth. (Fridolin Ambongo Besungu)
  • Proximity to Pope Francis: His appointment to the Council of Cardinals testifies to the Pope's confidence in him, although he has expressed disagreements on certain issues.
  • Social engagement: His action for human rights and against corruption reinforces his image as a committed and courageous pastor.
Weaknesses and Factors Limiting His Election
  • Tensions with civil authorities: His political stances have sometimes led to frictions with governments, particularly in the Democratic Republic of Congo, where he was the subject of a judicial investigation in 2024 for remarks deemed seditious.
  • Perception of divisive rhetoric: His critical statements toward the West, described as "decadent," may be perceived as polarizing within the College of Cardinals.
Ideological Positioning

Ambongo embodies a conservative line on doctrinal and moral issues, while being progressive on social and political issues. He defends a Church rooted in African cultural realities, opposing what he considers "cultural colonization" by the West.

Network and Weight Within the College of Cardinals

With his role within SECAM and the Council of Cardinals, Ambongo has a solid network, particularly among African cardinals and those sensitive to social justice issues. However, his conservative positions on certain subjects may limit his attractiveness to progressive cardinals. (Fridolin Ambongo Besungu)

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Fernando Filoni
Fernando Filoni
Italy, 79 ans
Moderate
Background and Functions

Fernando Filoni was born on April 15, 1946, in Manduria, in the Puglia region of Italy. Ordained a priest in 1970, he joined the Holy See's diplomatic service in 1981. His diplomatic career led him to sensitive posts, notably in Iran during the Iran-Iraq war, in Brazil, the Philippines, and especially in Iraq, where he was apostolic nuncio from 2001 to 2006. He remained at his post even during the American invasion of 2003, earning him special recognition for his courage and pastoral commitment.

From 2007 to 2011, he was Substitute for General Affairs in the Secretariat of State, a strategic position at the heart of Vatican governance. In 2011, Benedict XVI appointed him Prefect of the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples, a position he held until 2019. He was created a cardinal in 2012.

Since 2019, he has been Grand Master of the Equestrian Order of the Holy Sepulchre of Jerusalem, an honorary but influential position, particularly in terms of support for Christians in the Holy Land.

Analysis of Election Chances
Strengths and Assets
  • Extensive diplomatic experience: His long career in Vatican diplomacy, particularly in conflict zones, gives him valuable expertise in international relations and crisis management.
  • In-depth knowledge of Asia: His work in China and Hong Kong, where he closely followed the situation of the Church, gives him a unique perspective on the challenges of evangelization in Asia.
  • Solid network within the Curia: Having held key positions, he has close relationships with many cardinals and Vatican officials.
Weaknesses and Limiting Factors
  • Advanced age: At 79 years old, he is one of the oldest cardinal electors, which could be a deterrent for those who wish for a longer pontificate.
  • Conservative positioning: Though discreet, he is often associated with more traditional positions, which may not correspond to the aspirations of part of the College of Cardinals.
Ideological Positioning

Filoni is generally considered moderately conservative. He is attached to doctrinal tradition while being open to intercultural dialogues, particularly in Asia. His approach is pragmatic, centered on the Church's evangelizing mission.

Network and Weight Within the College of Cardinals

His experience and past functions ensure him a certain respect among the cardinals, particularly those appointed by Benedict XVI. However, he does not seem to have a sufficiently structured support bloc to carry a strong candidacy.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Leading papabile
Claudio Gugerotti
Claudio Gugerotti
Italy, 69 ans
Moderate-progressive
Career and Roles

Born on October 7, 1955, in Verona (Italy), Claudio Gugerotti was ordained a priest in 1982 for the Diocese of Verona. A member of the Pious Society of Don Nicola Mazza, he holds a degree in Oriental languages and literature from the University Ca' Foscari of Venice, a doctorate in Eastern ecclesiastical sciences from the Pontifical Oriental Institute, as well as a licentiate in sacred liturgy from the Pontifical Athenaeum Saint Anselm. (Brief biographies of 21 future Cardinals – FABC)

He taught patristics and Eastern liturgy at the Institute of Ecumenical Studies in Verona and at the Pontifical Oriental Institute. In 1985, he joined the Congregation for the Oriental Churches, becoming under-secretary in 1997. (Cardinal-to-be Claudio Gugerotti, expert in Eastern Europe - Aleteia)

In 2001, Pope John Paul II appointed him Archbishop of Ravello and Apostolic Nuncio to Georgia, Armenia, and Azerbaijan. He then served as nuncio in Belarus (2011–2015), Ukraine (2015–2020), and the United Kingdom (2020–2022). In November 2022, he was appointed Prefect of the Dicastery for the Eastern Churches, a position he holds until 2025. He was created a cardinal by Pope Francis on September 30, 2023. (Claudio Gugerotti, Claudio Gugerotti, Le cardinal Claudio Gugerotti envoyé par le pape François en Syrie ...)

He is a member of several dicasteries of the Roman Curia, including those for the doctrine of the faith, bishops, Christian unity, interreligious dialogue, culture and education, legislative texts, as well as the Pontifical Commission for the State of Vatican City.

Analysis of His Election Chances

Strengths and Advantages

  • Extensive diplomatic experience: Gugerotti has served as Apostolic Nuncio in several key countries, particularly in Eastern Europe, giving him a deep understanding of international relations and Eastern Churches.
  • Polyglot and academic: His mastery of multiple languages and his academic background make him well-suited to engage with various cultures and traditions within the Church.
Weaknesses and Limitations for His Election

  • Lack of diocesan pastoral experience: Having never been a residential bishop, some may feel he lacks direct pastoral experience with a diocesan community.
  • Primarily diplomatic profile: His career focused on diplomacy and the Curia may be seen as detached from the daily pastoral realities of the faithful.
Ideological Position

Claudio Gugerotti is generally regarded as moderate, with a particular sensitivity to the Eastern traditions of the Church. He is seen as loyal to Pope Francis's line, especially in terms of interreligious dialogue and attention to the peripheries.

Network and Influence Within the College of Cardinals

Created a cardinal by Pope Francis in 2023, Gugerotti enjoys the support of many cardinals appointed by Francis, who represent a majority in the electoral college. His diplomatic experience and established relationships within the Curia strengthen his network of influence.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report

Progressive Cardinals

These cardinals are favorable to Francis's reforms and wish to continue or deepen his orientation. They represent the most progressive wing of the papabili and are generally favorable to decentralization, greater inclusion, and adaptation of the Church to contemporary realities.

Leading papabile
Kurt Koch
Kurt Koch
Switzerland, 75 ans
Moderate-progressive
Background and Functions

Kurt Koch was born on March 15, 1950, in Emmenbrücke, in the canton of Lucerne, Switzerland. After studying theology at the University of Lucerne and at Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität in Munich, he obtained a licentiate in theology in 1975. He was ordained a priest on June 20, 1982, for the diocese of Basel. (Cardinal Kurt Koch - The College of Cardinals Report, Swiss Cardinal to Speak on Ecumenism | CUA, Kurt Koch)

From 1982 to 1989, he taught dogmatic and moral theology at the Catechetical Institute of Lucerne, then became professor of dogmatic and liturgical theology at the Faculty of Theology of Lucerne until his episcopal appointment. (Kurt Koch)

On August 21, 1995, he was appointed Bishop of Basel by Pope John Paul II, who personally consecrated him on January 6, 1996. He held this position until 2010. (Kurt Koch, Kurt Koch)

On July 1, 2010, Pope Benedict XVI appointed him president of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, a position he still holds. He is also president of the Commission for Religious Relations with Judaism. On November 20, 2010, he was created Cardinal-Deacon of Nostra Signora del Sacro Cuore. On May 3, 2021, he was elevated to the rank of Cardinal-Priest. (Kurt Koch)

Analysis of Election Chances as Pope
Strengths and Assets
  • Ecumenical experience: As president of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity since 2010, Cardinal Koch has extensive experience in interconfessional dialogue, particularly with Orthodox and Protestant Churches.
  • Solid theological training: With a doctorate in theology, he has taught dogmatic, moral, and liturgical theology, which gives him recognized intellectual authority. (Kurt Koch)
  • Knowledge of European realities: Having been a bishop in Switzerland for 15 years, he is well aware of the pastoral challenges in Western Europe, particularly secularization.
Weaknesses and Factors Limiting His Election
  • Advanced age: Born in 1950, he will be 75 at the May 2025 conclave, which could be a limiting factor for a long-term election.
  • Discreet profile: Although he holds important positions, he is less visible in the media than other cardinals, which could reduce his visibility among certain electors.
Ideological Positioning

Cardinal Koch is considered moderate, with a conservative sensibility on doctrinal matters, while being open to interreligious and ecumenical dialogue. He has defended religious freedom, including for Muslims in Switzerland, while calling for reciprocity in majority-Muslim countries. (Kurt Koch)

Network and Weight Within the College of Cardinals

As a member of several Roman dicasteries and having participated in the 2013 conclave, he has an extensive network within the Curia and the College of Cardinals. His long experience at the Vatican strengthens his institutional credibility.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Leading papabile
Pietro Parolin
Pietro Parolin
Italy, 70 ans
Moderate-progressive
Background and Functions

Born on January 17, 1955, in Schiavon, in the province of Vicenza (Italy), Pietro Parolin was ordained a priest in 1980. After a brief pastoral experience, he joined the Pontifical Ecclesiastical Academy in 1983, thus beginning a diplomatic career within the Holy See. He served successively in the nunciatures in Nigeria, Mexico, and Venezuela, before joining the Secretariat of State in 2002.

In 2009, he was appointed apostolic nuncio to Venezuela, then, in 2013, Pope Francis appointed him as Vatican Secretary of State, a position he held until the Pope's death in April 2025. As Secretary of State, Parolin played a central role in Vatican diplomacy, particularly in the controversial agreement with China on the appointment of bishops and in the rapprochement between the United States and Cuba in 2014.

In 2014, he was created a cardinal by Pope Francis. In 2018, he was elevated to the rank of cardinal-bishop. Following the death of Cardinal Giovanni Battista Re, Parolin became the Dean of the College of Cardinal Electors, thus presiding over the 2025 conclave.

Analysis of Election Chances
Strengths and Assets
  • Knowledge of the Curia: Having served as Secretary of State for more than a decade, he masters the inner workings of the Roman Curia and the internal challenges of the Church.
  • Multilingualism: Parolin speaks Italian, French, English, and Spanish fluently, which facilitates his international interactions.
Weaknesses and Factors Limiting His Election
  • Lack of pastoral experience: His career having primarily unfolded in diplomacy, he has little experience as a pastor of a diocese, which could be perceived as a handicap.
Ideological Positioning

Parolin is considered a moderate, or even a centrist. He supports Pope Francis's reforms while adopting a prudent approach on sensitive subjects. He has expressed conservative positions on homosexual marriage but has shown openness to discussing priestly celibacy and the role of women in the Church. (Politics aside for one day, world leaders to gather at Vatican and ..., Quién es Pietro Parolin, el candidato italiano que suena con más fuerza para ser el nuevo Papa de Roma)

Network and Weight Within the College of Cardinals

As Dean of the College of Cardinal Electors and former Secretary of State, Parolin enjoys great visibility and an extensive network. He is respected for his ability to navigate the complexities of the Curia and to maintain stable diplomatic relations. (Conclave de 2025)

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Leading papabile
Peter Kodwo Appiah Turkson
Peter Kodwo Appiah Turkson
Ghana, 76 ans
Moderate-progressive
Career and Functions

Born on October 11, 1948, in Wassaw Nsuta, Ghana, Peter Turkson is the fourth of a family of ten children. From a modest background, he was ordained a priest in 1975 after studies in Ghana, the United States, and Rome, where he obtained a doctorate in Sacred Scripture from the Pontifical Biblical Institute.

In 1992, he was appointed Archbishop of Cape Coast, thus becoming the Primate of Ghana. In 2003, John Paul II created him cardinal, making him the first Ghanaian cardinal in history. He chaired the Ghana Catholic Bishops' Conference from 1997 to 2005.

In 2009, Benedict XVI appointed him President of the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace. In 2016, he became the first Prefect of the Dicastery for Promoting Integral Human Development, a position he held until 2021. Since 2022, he has been Chancellor of the Pontifical Academy of Sciences and the Pontifical Academy of Social Sciences.

Analysis of election chances
Strengths and assets
  • International experience: His career combines solid pastoral experience in Africa and high-level responsibilities at the Vatican, particularly in the areas of social justice and human development.
  • Symbolic profile: As the first Ghanaian cardinal, his election would represent a historic turning point, highlighting the growth of Catholicism in Africa, which represents about 20% of the global Catholic population.
  • Linguistic skills: He masters several languages, including English, French, Italian, and German, which facilitates his interactions within the universal Church.
Weaknesses and factors that could limit his election
  • Advanced age: At 76, he is close to the age limit for conclave electors, which could prompt cardinals to favor a younger candidate for a potentially longer pontificate.
  • Conservative positions: His stances on issues such as homosexuality and Islam have sparked controversies, notably the dissemination of an alarmist video about Muslim demographic growth in Europe during a synod in 2012.
Ideological positioning

Cardinal Turkson is generally perceived as conservative on doctrinal matters, while being engaged on social and environmental issues. He notably collaborated on Pope Francis's encyclical Laudato si', highlighting environmental and social justice.

Network and weight within the College of Cardinals

His long career within the Roman Curia and his relationships with Popes John Paul II, Benedict XVI, and Francis give him a respected stature. However, he is not considered a leader of a specific group of cardinals, which could limit his direct influence during the conclave.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Leading papabile
Stephen Brislin
Stephen Brislin
South Africa, 68 ans
Progressive
Background and Functions

Stephen Brislin, born on September 24, 1956, in Welkom, South Africa, is an influential prelate of the South African Catholic Church. Of Scottish and Irish descent, he studied psychology at the University of Cape Town, philosophy at St. John Vianney Seminary in Pretoria, theology at Mill Hill Missionary Institute in London, and obtained a degree from the Catholic University of Louvain. Ordained a priest on November 19, 1983, for the diocese of Kroonstad, he was appointed bishop of the same diocese in 2006, then Archbishop of Cape Town in 2009. He held that position until October 2024, when he was transferred to the Archdiocese of Johannesburg. (Stephen Brislin)

Brislin was president of the Southern African Catholic Bishops' Conference (SACBC) from 2013 to 2019 and president of the Inter-Regional Meeting of Bishops of Southern Africa (IMBISA) from 2012 to 2016. He was created a cardinal by Pope Francis at the consistory of September 30, 2023, receiving the title of Cardinal-Priest of Santa Maria Domenica Mazzarello. He is also a member of the Dicastery for the Causes of Saints since October 2023. (Stephen Brislin)

Analysis of His Election Chances
Strengths and Assets
  • Pastoral and diplomatic experience: Brislin has led two of South Africa's largest archdioceses and played a key role in the synods on the family in 2014 and 2015, where he was elected rapporteur of a working group. He has also participated in diplomatic missions, notably to Palestine. (Stephen Brislin)
  • Proximity to Pope Francis: His appointment as cardinal in 2023 and his transfer to Johannesburg in 2024 testify to the confidence the Pope places in him. (Stephen Brislin)
  • Representative of the Global South: As an African cardinal, he embodies a growing Church and could respond to the desire for a more representative pontificate of the realities of the South.
Weaknesses and Limitations
  • Limited international visibility: Despite his responsibilities, Brislin remains little known outside Southern Africa, which could work against him compared to more high-profile candidates.
  • Limited network within the Curia: Although he is a member of a dicastery, he has not held top positions in Rome, which could limit his influence among cardinal electors.
Ideological Positioning

Brislin is considered a moderate, aligned with Pope Francis's pastoral vision. He supported open approaches during the family synods, while remaining faithful to doctrine. His episcopate is marked by attention to social issues and justice, without adopting radical positions. (Stephen Brislin)

Network and Weight Within the College of Cardinals

As president of the SACBC and IMBISA, Brislin has forged strong ties with the bishops of Southern Africa. His recent elevation to the cardinalate and his appointment to Johannesburg enhance his stature. However, his influence remains primarily regional, and he will have to rely on the support of cardinals who share his pastoral vision to hope to be elected. (Stephen Brislin)

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Leading papabile
Luis Antonio Tagle
Luis Antonio Tagle
Philippines, 67 ans
Very progressive
Career and Functions

Born on June 21, 1957, in Manila, Philippines, Luis Antonio Gokim Tagle is a major figure in the Asian Catholic Church. Ordained a priest in 1982, he was appointed Bishop of Imus in 2001, then Archbishop of Manila in 2011. In 2012, Pope Benedict XVI created him cardinal.

In December 2019, Pope Francis appointed him Prefect of the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples. With the entry into force of the apostolic constitution Praedicate Evangelium in 2022, this congregation was integrated into the new Dicastery for Evangelization, where Tagle served as pro-prefect of the section for first evangelization and new particular Churches.

Tagle also served as president of Caritas Internationalis from 2015 to 2023. However, in November 2022, the Vatican announced a reorganization of Caritas, citing "real deficiencies" in management, which led to the end of his mandate at the head of the organization.

In February 2024, he was elevated to the rank of Officer of the Legion of Honor by France, in recognition of his commitment to international solidarity.

Analysis of his election chances
Strengths and assets
  • International profile: The first Asian cardinal to hold high-level positions at the Vatican, Tagle embodies the universality of the Church and could strengthen its presence in Asia, a continent where Catholicism is growing.
  • Proximity to Pope Francis: Considered a close ally of Pope Francis, he shares his vision of a synodal Church, open and turned towards the peripheries.
  • Communication skills: Recognized for his speaking talents and ability to establish dialogue with various cultures and religions, he is often nicknamed "the Asian Francis".
Weaknesses and limiting factors
  • Management of Caritas Internationalis: The reorganization of Caritas in 2022, under his presidency, raised questions about his administrative management skills.
  • Perception of youth: At 67, some cardinals might prefer an older candidate for a potentially shorter pontificate.
Ideological positioning

Tagle is generally perceived as progressive, aligned with Pope Francis's reforms. He supports an inclusive pastoral approach, emphasizing mercy, interreligious dialogue, and social engagement.

Network and weight within the College of Cardinals

Having been appointed cardinal by Benedict XVI and having held key positions under Francis's pontificate, Tagle benefits from cross-cutting recognition within the College of Cardinals. His active participation in synods and his role at the Vatican strengthen his visibility and influence.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
José Tolentino de Mendonça
José Tolentino de Mendonça
Portugal, 59 ans
Progressive
Background and Functions

Born on December 15, 1965, in Machico, on the island of Madeira, Portugal, José Tolentino de Mendonça was ordained a priest on July 28, 1990. With a doctorate in biblical theology, he distinguished himself through a notable academic and literary career, publishing works of poetry, essays, and theater. (José Tolentino de Mendonça)

In 2011, he became a consultant to the Pontifical Council for Culture. In June 2018, Pope Francis appointed him Archivist and Librarian of the Holy Roman Church, and he was consecrated as the titular bishop of Suava on July 28, 2018. On October 5, 2019, he was created a cardinal-deacon of Santi Domenico e Sisto. (Profiles of Pope Francis' New Cardinals - National Catholic Register, José Tolentino de Mendonça)

On September 26, 2022, he was appointed Prefect of the Dicastery for Culture and Education, a strategic position within the Roman Curia. He is also a member of several important dicasteries, including those for the Evangelization of Peoples, the Causes of Saints, Bishops, Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, as well as the Doctrine of the Faith. (José Tolentino de Mendonça)

Analysis of Election Chances
Strengths and Assets
  • Intellectual and cultural profile: Recognized for his theological depth and literary sensitivity, he embodies a respected intellectual figure within the Church.
  • Proximity to Pope Francis: His successive appointments to key positions testify to the confidence that Pope Francis places in him.
  • Openness to dialogue: His commitment to a Church open to the contemporary world and cultural dialogue aligns with the current orientations of the Church.
Weaknesses and Limiting Factors
  • Progressive positioning: His positions in favor of an inclusive pastoral approach, particularly towards LGBTQ+ people, raise reservations among conservative cardinals.
  • Controversies: His introduction to a work of feminist theology was criticized for its support of controversial positions within the Church.
Ideological Positioning

Cardinal Tolentino de Mendonça is considered one of the most progressive papabili, advocating for an open, dialoguing Church attentive to contemporary realities. (José Tolentino de Mendonça)

Network and Weight Within the College of Cardinals

He benefits from the support of the Community of Sant'Egidio, influential in progressive ecclesiastical circles. His proximity to Pope Francis and his responsibilities within the Curia strengthen his network and influence. (José Tolentino de Mendonça)

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report
Leading papabile
Matteo Maria Zuppi
Matteo Maria Zuppi
Italy, 69 ans
Very progressive
Career and Functions

Born in Rome on October 11, 1955, Matteo Maria Zuppi is the fifth of six children from a family deeply rooted in the Catholic Church. His father was a journalist at L'Osservatore Romano and his mother was the niece of Cardinal Carlo Confalonieri, former Dean of the College of Cardinals. He was ordained a priest in 1981 after studies in theology at the Pontificia Università Lateranense and in literature at La Sapienza University in Rome.

Zuppi served for 19 years as vicar and then parish priest of the basilica of Santa Maria in Trastevere, a nerve center of the Community of Sant'Egidio, a lay movement engaged in interreligious dialogue and peace mediation. He played a key role in the negotiations leading to the Rome Peace Accords in 1992, ending the civil war in Mozambique.

In 2012, he was appointed auxiliary bishop of Rome by Benedict XVI, then Archbishop of Bologna in 2015 by Pope Francis. The latter created him cardinal in 2019 and appointed him president of the Italian Episcopal Conference in 2022.

In 2023, Pope Francis designated him as a special envoy for peace in Ukraine, a mission that led him to meet with officials in Kyiv, Moscow, and Washington to promote humanitarian solutions and diplomatic dialogue.

Analysis of his election chances
Strengths and assets
  • Diplomatic experience: His role in peace negotiations in Mozambique and his mission in Ukraine demonstrate his skills in mediation and international diplomacy.
  • Proximity to Pope Francis: Zuppi embodies continuity with Francis's pontificate, sharing a pastoral vision centered on the peripheries, inclusion, and social justice.
  • National leadership: As president of the Italian Episcopal Conference, he benefits from a strategic position within the Italian Church, influential in the College of Cardinals.
  • Pastoral profile: His accessible approach and commitment to the marginalized reinforce his image as a pastor close to the people.
Weaknesses and limiting factors
  • Progressive perception: His open positions on issues such as welcoming migrants or pastoral care for LGBT people may raise reluctance among conservative cardinals.
  • Age: At 69, some electors might prefer a younger candidate for a potentially longer pontificate.
  • Association with Sant'Egidio: His proximity to this community, although respected, could be perceived as an external influence on Church governance.
Ideological positioning

Zuppi is considered a progressive cardinal, aligned with Pope Francis's priorities: attention to the poor, interreligious dialogue, integral ecology, and pastoral openness. He supports a synodal and inclusive Church, while respecting doctrinal tradition.

Network and weight within the College of Cardinals

As a major figure in the Italian Church and close to Pope Francis, Zuppi has a solid network among the cardinals appointed by the latter. His influence also extends through his international engagements and his role in diplomatic missions.

Vatican BiographyCollege of Cardinals Report